• Home   /  
  • Archive by category "1"

The Dagger Scene Macbeth Analysis Essays

That evening Banquo and his son Fleance walk through a torch-lit hall in Inverness. Fleance remarks the time, after midnight, but Banquo responds he wishes to stay awake despite his fatigue due to his sleep in recent times, which has brought about ‘cursed thoughts’. Macbeth appears and Banquo, surprised to see him still awake, reveals that the king is asleep and that he recently had a dream about the ‘three weird sisters’; he claims the witches have imparted ‘some truth’ to Macbeth who (deceptively) says he has not considered their meeting with since the met them in the woods. He and Banquo agree to discuss the meeting in due course and Banquo and Fleance then depart. Macbeth, left alone, suddenly views a dagger floating towards him, handle aimed at his hand and tip directed towards where Duncan sleeps. After trying and failing to grab the dagger Macbeth wonders if it is simply a ‘dagger of the mind, a false creation/ Proceeding from the heat-oppressed brain’. Macbeth looks at it closely and believes he sees blood on the weapon, but soon convinces himself it is simply representative of his unease at the task ahead. Despite this unease Macbeth steadies himself and upon hearing a bell toll (Lady Macbeth’s signal that the chamberlains have fallen into sleep), prays the earth ‘hear not steps’ as he moves towards where Duncan sleeps.

Analysis

Two episodes from this scene should be noted. Firstly, Macbeth treats Banquo with distrust by telling him he has not thought of the witches or their prophecies since the meeting, which we know is a lie. Why does he act in such a manner? It might be that he does not even wish to tell his closest friend that he is considering regicide, which suggests his realization that what he is contemplating is undeniably wrong. While he does mention discussing the prophecies at a later time this may be designed to prevent Banquo from becoming suspicious at his current lack of concern for the prophecies, especially considering his enthusiastic response to them when they met the witches. It may be also be considered that Macbeth treats Banquo in such a manner as he already sees his friend as a threat to his lineage, as the first prophecy stated he would become king while the second foretold that Banquo’s lineage would assume the crown; this is a fear that grows later in the play and causes Macbeth to eventually have his friend murdered.

Second is the image of the floating dagger, which reveals several significant issues. While it may be argued as to whether the dagger is real or not, it seems most likely it is not and is rather a manifestation of Macbeth’s thoughts and unease considering the forthcoming events. Even more significant is the presentation of the dagger, which suggests that at this moment Macbeth is committed to the deed; as said the dagger represents Macbeth’s emotions concerning the forthcoming act of regicide. This weapon has blood on it and in the play blood is linked to harmful, violent actions (indeed Macbeth speaks of bloodiness in this scene, speaking of ‘blade and dudgeon of blood’ and ‘bloody business’), indicating that when Macbeth considers regicide he no longer wonders about whether to commit the action or not. Tthis is linked to the theme of imagination; Macbeth’s imagining the act of regicide has now increased to the extent that he no longer imagines the act in terms of possibility but rather certainty, as he admits he is led by the ‘dagger of the mind’ which ‘marshal the way’. Other details confirm this, such as the handle facing Macbeth’s hand and the tip directing him to the chamber of the man he will murder. The end of the scene confirms this; Macbeth no longer frets over whether to do as his wife wishes but rather that no one hears him while he does so, a concern which is extremely insignificant when compared to Macbeth’s worries earlier.

Points of note

As seen earlier with Banquo, Macbeth speaks of deception and here wonders if he is being deceived, commenting of ‘being unprepared, our will became the servant to defect’ and of the ‘dagger of the mind, a false creation, proceeding from heat oppressed brain’. Interestingly, that which he talks about deceiving him has nothing to do with external forces; rather he speaks of ‘will’ and ‘the mind’, suggesting he is being deceived by himself. This indicates how rife deception is in the world, as no other is needed for deception to occur. Secondly, it might be indicative of Macbeth’s lack of self-control; as mentioned earlier when discussing how he did not stop when killing an opponent in war but rather cut his head off, and also with the increasing level of imagination that it is overpowering Macbeth currently. As a result Macbeth begins to lose concept of normality as he is placed in an unfamiliar position: ‘I have thee not, and yet I see thee still… for it is knell,/ That summons thee to heaven or hell’.

This is the first scene in which see Fleance and his presence shows Macbeth in a bad light. While Macbeth saw Malcolm and Duncan as obstacles to his desire/ ambition, the crown this did not resonate a great shock in the audience as all three are adult characters and are associated with a world in which murder and somewhat immoral actions are commonplace. As a result, while Macbeth murdering one or both of these would be considered immoral by the audience this would not be extremely shocking considering the world of the play. When Fleance appears we are reminded that the witches foretold that Banquo’s family would assume the crown and thus Fleance assumes the role of obstacle for Macbeth, which he saw Malcolm as earlier; Macbeth will presumably have to kill Fleance to retain his crown by the play’s end. Fleance’s age is not specified but the mention of him as Banquo’s son suggests he is considerably younger than the other characters, and his youth can be associated with innocence. As a result, the prospect of Macbeth killing him to retain his crown transforms the titular character in our eyes; killing adults is one thing, murdering youths is another.

Related Notes

Crucial Scene In Macbeth: The Dagger Soliloquy

Poem:

Is this a dagger which I see before me,

The handle toward my hand? Come, let me clutch thee:

I have thee not, and yet I see thee still.

Art thou not, fatal vision, sensible

to feeling as to sight? Or art thou but

a dagger of the mind, a false creation,

Proceeding form the heat-oppressed brain?

I see thee yet, in form as palpable

As this which now I draw.

Thou marrshall'st me the way that I was going,

And such an instrument I was to use.

Mine eyes are made the fools o'th'other sense,

Or else worth all the rest. I see thee still

And on thy blade and dudgeon gouts of bleed,

Which was not so before.

There's no such thing:

It is the bloody business which informs

Thus to mine eyes.

Now o'er the one half-world

Nature seems dead, and wicked dreams abuse

The curtained sleep. Witchcraft celebrates

Pale Hecate's off'rings, and withered murder,

Alarumed by his sentinel, the wolf,

Whose howl's his watch, thus with his stealthy pace,

With Tarquin's ravishing strides, towards his design

Moves like a ghost.

Thou sure and firm-set earth,

Hear not my steps, which way they walk, for fear

Thy very stone prate of my whereabout,

And take the present horror form the time,

Which now suits with it.

Whiles I threat, he lives; ...Words to the heat of deeds too cold breath gives.

How this scene contributes to our understanding of character and play:

So far, the play has hurdled through seven scenes of mounting tension and now tithers on the threshold of regicide. At this point, Shakespeare freezes the action. In the tension of silence, both character and play develop on new levels.

For Macbeth, this soliloquy, in A.C. Bradley's words: "is where the powerful workings of his imagination rises to a new level of visible intensity as his conscience manifests itself as an air-drawn dagger." This is the first glimpse of a vigorous imagination from which stems the guilt-inspired hallucinations that will torment him. Bradley concludes that "his imagination is a substitute for conscience", but this isn't all. This soliloquy expresses macbeth's most profound fears and hopes, and the dagger symbolises the fulfilment of his black desires.

It conveys his internal struggle to divest himself of fear and scruples to become wholly committed to murder. His attempt to grab the dagger indicates his desperation to accomplish the deed before any regrets. Yet the past tense in "the way I was going" suggests that realisation of his desires has blunted blind courage.

Macbeth's difficulty in overcoming his conscience demonstrates that murder goes against his person, and he has to fight his own nature to carry it out....

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

Lady Macbeth's soliloquy, Act I. What dramatic atmosphere(s) is/are created in Lady Macbeth's soliloquy? What does this soliloquy reflect about Lady Macbeth? How does Lady Macbeth contribute to the...

1932 words - 8 pages Untitled Advanced Literature 2010 Response to Lady Macbeth's Soliloquy

The Characterisation of Lady Macbeth in Act 1 Scene 5

1130 words - 5 pages The Characterisation of Lady Macbeth in Act 1 Scene 5 The Macbeth scenes are generally intended to express tragedy in the play. Much of the scene in Act 1 Scene 5 is concentrated on Lady Macbeth, because she has dominance over her husband. The scene commences with Lady Macbeth in solitary. She had received a letter from Macbeth that he had been announced Thane of Cawdor after a victorious battle. Macbeth had also written...

Act 2 Scene 2 as a Turning Point in the Play for Macbeth and Lady Macbeth

1924 words - 8 pages Act 2 Scene 2 as a Turning Point in the Play for Macbeth and Lady Macbeth On the way home from a courageous battle the play begins with Macbeth and Banquo's noble and victorious return. During their journey they are greeted by 3 witches whom prophesize Macbeth's rise to power as King. Macbeth is very curious about these strange beings and their message and starts to wonder if it really is quite possible to find...

The Use of Soliloquy in Shakespeare's Hamlet

1150 words - 5 pages A Soliloquy is a dramatic convention, in which the character stands alone on stage, speaking. Originally it was a plot device, to enable a character to tell the audience what he planned to do next, for example, in the course of revenge. But the device is heightened in Shakespeare as it enables a character to reveal the ‘inner soul’ to the audience without telling the other characters. It is usual that one discovers more of a...

Lady Macbeth in Act One Scene Seven

2359 words - 9 pages Lady Macbeth in Act One Scene Seven In act 1 scene 7 we see that Macbeth is struggling with the moral and ethical turmoil of his conscience as to weather he should commit the sacrilegious act of regicide “with his surcease , success” Macbeth feels that if it were to be the “be all and end all” he would do it , however he fears the repercussions in that it may “return to plague th’inventor” this is a mere shadow of the...

Critical Analysis of Iago's Soliloquy in Act 2 Scene 3 of Othello by William Shakespeare

807 words - 3 pages Critical Analysis of Iago's Soliloquy in Act 2 Scene 3 of Othello by William Shakespeare Iago’s second soliloquy is very revealing. It shows him shaping a plan out of the confusion of his emotionally charged thoughts. Iago examines his own thoughts, especially his hatred for Othello: “The Moor, howbeit that I endure him not” He is also suffering from the “poisonous mineral” of jealousy that still swirls around the rumour...

Additional Scene to Shakespeare's Macbeth. I wrote Act VI, Scene 1, after Shakespeare concludes the play in Act 5.

1293 words - 5 pages Characters:Donalbain: Malcolm's brother who early in the play fled to Ireland after his father's (Duncan)death. He is not seen the remainder of the play, until now.Witches: The 3 troublesome sisters who plagued MacBeth and contributed to his downfall for their own...

Macbeth-Who is the third murderer who appears in Act III, scene iii?

1038 words - 4 pages Write an analysis of the identity of the third murderer in Macbeth and why he appears in Act III, scene iii. With close reference to the text, you need to support your choice as to whom you believe Shakespeare intended that extra person to be.Through carefully reading the text, I believe it is up to the individual's imagination to determine who the third murderer is. Shakespeare is not clear on this issue and I have a few theories on...

"How Would You Direct The Actors In Act 3, Scene 4 of Shakespeare's Macbeth?"

2351 words - 9 pages Shakespeare's Macbeth is a most intriguing play for it's time. Not many plays beforehand had involved the death of a king wrongfully, as it was believed that the King was chosen by God Himself, and that to kill a King is a mortal sin. Shakespeare, however, managed to fit the murder of a king, the benefits and the down falls of Macbeth's plot to rule. 's Macbeth is definitely of the horror genre.Act 3, Scene 4, Shakespeare portrays how...

Ambition, death, and power: themes found in the first scene of Macbeth by Shakespeare

734 words - 3 pages During a low point in Macbeth’s life he faces struggles with power, ambition and the thoughts of death surrounding him. Grabbing ahold of him strongly he is shown many ideas that are very promising at first, especially when the witches tell him of all of the control he could have, he wants the power, the fame and will do anything to get it. In act 1, scene 3, lines 140-145 Macbeth is recalling a conversation with the witches which brings about...

How Crucial Was Lenin's Role In The November Revolution?

725 words - 3 pages Following his death in 1924 Lenin was raised to the status of a god-like figure by Stalin. Lenin's role in the November revolution was therefore seen as crucial. However, was this merely to allow Stalin to gain power by presenting himself as a faithful successor to Lenin? The varying schools of historical interpretation give differing views as to how crucial Lenin's role was in the revolution. Although Lenin spent the majority of...

One thought on “The Dagger Scene Macbeth Analysis Essays

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *